Crypto Miners are No Minor Deal

When most people think about cryptocurrency markets, miners aren't usually the first thing that comes to mind. While big investors, or “whales,” often steal the spotlight, miners quietly play a significant role in shaping where prices head next. They aren't just there to process transactions in the background—they have the power to shift market trends.

Among the many indicators and metrics we've talked about in our content at Santiment, one crucial factor to keep an eye on is how much cryptocurrency miners are holding. When miners choose to hold onto their coins rather than selling, it’s often a sign that they expect prices to rise, which can create positive momentum in the market. However, when they start offloading large amounts, it can put downward pressure on prices.

Miners’ influence on the market is linked to their role in supplying new cryptocurrency. If they hold onto their rewards instead of selling, it limits the available supply, which can help drive prices up. This can signal to other market participants that miners are confident prices will increase. On the flip side, when miners sell in large quantities, it introduces more coins into circulation, which can push prices down. Essentially, miners’ decisions to hold or sell often directly affect the balance of supply and demand, making their actions a crucial part of understanding the market.

Mining is an energy-intensive process, and one of the biggest factors that affect profitability is electricity costs. If the price of electricity rises or cryptocurrency prices fall too low, it might cost more to mine than the miners are earning in rewards. In such cases, miners may be forced to sell their holdings to cover their operational costs, which increases the supply of cryptocurrency on the market and can contribute to price drops. In bear markets, when prices are already struggling, this can create a snowball effect, leading some miners to shut down or scale back their operations.

Miners tend to adjust their strategies depending on the market cycle. When prices are rising during bull markets, miners might hold onto their coins longer, anticipating even higher profits. But in bear markets, they are more likely to sell what they’ve mined, which can put further pressure on prices. It’s a tricky balancing act, and miners are always trying to decide when the right moment to sell is. Their decisions can significantly influence the market’s direction.

This goes for Ethereum and many altcoins as well. Take a look at the sudden surge in miner balances going up right as the Bitcoin ETF's were announced in the second week of January, 2024. There was a swift run-up in the ETH/BTC price, followed by a long-term downturn after they dumped less than a week later:

And yes, meme coins like Dogecoin, or more obscure assets, are regularly mined as well. If it's a very speculative-driven asset, you can often pick up an inverse indication between what miners are doing and where the altcoin is going price-wise compared to Bitcoin. We noticed a huge dump by miners in late January, 2024, followed by a massive surge in DOGE/BTC the next 2 months. So with this example, of course don't solely view miner accumulation as a bullish signal:

Some of you may remember this short clip from the popular US-based comedy show Silicon Valley, involving a cryptocurrency miner (named Gilfoyle) setting an alert for himself whenever the market (and electricity) conditions align to reveal that it's profitable to mine Bitcoin. This was, and still is, a very real thing!

Larger mining pools and institutional mining operations can have an even bigger impact on market prices. When a substantial amount of cryptocurrency is sent to exchanges by major mining groups, it can signal an upcoming price drop as traders anticipate a large sell-off. These big mining operations have the resources to affect prices through their sheer volume, which makes their behavior especially important to watch.

This template here may come in handy for you, as you can look for moments where the supply of Bitcoin is rising and miner balances are simultaneously falling. You can see this was very evident in the March, 2021 top and the March, 2024 tops:

For anyone looking to predict market movements, analyzing miner behavior can provide valuable insights. On-chain analysis tools allow you to track the movements of miner wallets. If miners are transferring large amounts of cryptocurrency to exchanges, it could be a sign that they’re preparing to sell, which can create additional selling pressure. Santiment offers miner balance activity, giving traders a glimpse into potential market trends. Tracking miner unspent supply, or the amount of cryptocurrency held by miners that hasn’t been sold, can also provide clues about their confidence in future price increases.

Another key metric is hashrate, which measures the total computing power miners contribute to the network. A rising hashrate usually suggests miners are optimistic about future profitability, while a declining hashrate might indicate that miners are scaling back due to falling prices. Hashrate fluctuations can reveal miner sentiment and help forecast broader market trends, making it an essential indicator of overall network health.

Occasionally, the term "miner capitulation" comes up during market downturns. This happens when miners, especially smaller or less efficient ones, can no longer cover their costs and are forced to sell off their holdings or shut down their operations entirely. This wave of selling can drive prices lower in the short term but may also signal that the market is reaching a bottom, as sell pressure decreases once weaker miners exit.

It can be a bit tricky to find correlations related to social media mentions of "miners" or "mining", and relate this to how markets react immediately after. There are a few interesting spikes in mentions over the past month that immediately led to local tops, but you can be the judge on whether it has meaning. If anything, the lack of correlation is a good indication that the crowd really has very little idea on how miners will behave, and relatedly, miners are not very influenced by the crowd:

Mining behavior doesn’t just respond to the market; it can also spark significant market moves. For instance, Bitcoin’s halving events, where block rewards are reduced, often lead to price spikes due to the reduced supply of newly mined coins. Fewer new coins coming into circulation while demand remains steady or grows can create upward pressure on prices. Understanding these miner-related dynamics can give you a leg up when navigating the highs and lows of the crypto market. So, don’t overlook the miners—they’re no minor deal in determining where prices head next.

-----

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the post are for general informational purposes only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual or on any specific security or investment product.